
I baked these potatoes, tossed with seasonings (garlic salt, pepper, paprika and parsley) and topped with chunks of butter.
They looked pretty but tasted very dry. I used a glass lid on this dish while they baked. I probably baked them for too long or on too high a temperature (350*F), or maybe I should have added a little water to the bottom of the dish?
At any rate, I dipped mine in sour cream as I ate them and they were more like oven fries than the moist seasoned potato chunks I had envisioned!
What's your favorite way to prepare potatoes? I need some fresh inspiration!

Using our Amazon.com search boxes when making purchases helps support this site. Thanks for your support!
Comments
I slice my potatoes, quickly
I slice my potatoes, quickly dip in olive oil, sprinkle with herbs and/or spices, add some onion, and bake uncovered, stirring at least once. Absolutely delicious!
I often do someting similar
I often do someting similar to this, but instead of butter I toss the potatoes with olive oil. I bake covered at 350* for 20min and then uncover and bake 10 min more.
But really my favorite always has ben and always will be mashed potatoes.MMMMMM....I think they just won a place on the menue tonight.
EVOO
I agree; olive oil is the way to go. I think you could still dot them with butter if you wanted (I've never tried both at once), but the evoo seems to really absorb deeply into the potatoes and does well with the baking. I don't cover them, and probably bake them 30 minutes or so (I guess the timing would depend on how big your chunks were cut), stirring every once in a while.
~Arlene
Parmesan Potatoes
A recipe I've used regularly for the past year and even taught my kids to make is so simple yet we all love them. I'll tell you my "make it as simple as possible directions" which have worked for us. First, cut potatoes in half length-wise (think the original recipe called for new potatoes but I don't always have those so we generally just use Russets), melt one stick of butter in the bottom of a 9x13 pan (I stick the pan in the oven as it preheats and I'm cutting the potatoes). Place the potatoes cut side down in the pan in a single layer and then sprinkle Parmesan cheese over then in the desired amount. I've also taken to putting some salt on them at this point. Bake at 350°for 45-60 minutes. Easy bit good.
Just copied down this recipe
Just copied down this recipe and will make it tonight!! Thanks! :D
I do them the same way here...
except in the summer when I do not want to turn on the oven... Olive oil... heavy cast iron pan on the stove or grill... with garlic pepper...
YUMMY! trick is not to move them much... if you do they do not get as crispy on the bottom.
That is the best part!
Cooking potatoes
Mashed w/ onion powder, salt, pepper, butter, milk
Homefried with onions, in bacon fat w/ salt, pepper, cayenne, paprika
boiled and topped w/ butter, salt, pepper, parsley
oven roasted w/ olive oil, salt, pepper, rosemary
cooked along side a roast, chicken
quartered and simmered in chicken stock w/ slivered onions
scallopped
au gratin
french fried
DO you have any of the dry potatoes left? can they be mashed and turned into potatoe pancakes? what about scallopped/au gratin? can they be folded into an omelette?
I would say the same... but
I would say the same... but cooked uncovered
baked potato idea
I also go with the olive oil. Tossing them in olive oil with any variety of seasonings allows you to adjust the flavor to match the rest of the meal. If you're going Italian, use Italian seasonings. We love spicy stuff, so some chipotle seasonings work really well!
I also toss mine with olive
I also toss mine with olive oil and herbs/spices. I bake at about 400 for half an hour or so. They do turn out more like an oven fry, which is the result I was looking for
I use EVOO and a variety of
I use EVOO and a variety of spice whatever goes with what else I am making, and roast about 400 for 30 mins depending on the size of potatoes , comes out crunchy on the outside and soft and moist on the inside
The Mother in law's Potatoes
At our house we have my husband's mom's potatoes and everyone LOVES them. She was a from the box cook and only makes things that are quick.
Chunk up 3 or 4 potatoes. Put them in a casserole dish, chop a few tablespoons of butter into the dish (I usually use about 3 T). Sprinkle with Lipton's Onion soup mix!! Mix it up and cook at 350 for about 30-45 minutes. I use a lidded casserole dish, but take off the lid in the last 10 minutes or so. Stir a few times while cooking.
Turns out great every time!!
Our favorite oven baked potatoes
My Mom has always done the melted butter method mentioned above. I think the key factor here is that the butter/oil is liquid, and coats the potatoes as the bake...this locks in the moisture and keeps them from getting dry. And it also develops a nice crispy browned coating.
My Mom dices her potatoes, adds some salt/pepper and fresh diced garlic, and then parmesan over the top. She bakes hers at 400 degrees for 30-45 min, stirring a few times to brown all edges.
YUM!
Hi Tammy,
This a dream come true post for me. I absolutely love potatoes! We ate them at least twice a day growing up and all of us kids still love potatoes.
I can't wait to see the yummy recipes other readers share:)
Here is a link to one of my favorite recipes: Mashed Potato Casserole
http://farmhomelife.blogspot.com/2008/02/best-mashed-potato-casserole.html
I also fry them with a little onion and serve them augratin style. Of course scalloped potatoes are good too. About once a year I'll make homemade french fries and serve them with fish and coleslaw.
Take Care,
Trixie
Yummy Potatoes
OK - my son hates potatoes - but he actually said he liked them when I fixed Pioneer Woman's "Crash Hot Potatoes" (or some such name - we renamed them smashed potatoes).
First boil some little new potatoes...then put them on a oiled cookie sheet and smash them down with a potato masher or heavy can...then brush on some olive oil, coarse salt and Italian seasoning. Bake at about 400 - 450 degrees until browned.
These are super!
Mashed...
I love 'em mashed with cream cheese instead of butter and then beat in some whole milk. Sooo yummy and creamy! Of course, we also use salt and pepper to taste. I love oven roasted potatoes, but haven't perfected that yet!!
Julie
www.juliesrecipebox.blogspot.com
roasted potatos with veggies..
I have a favorite reciepe that I found in a kids' cookbook, and we all just love it. Here it is:
I cut up potatoes with skin on in small chunks, as I do
the sweet potatoes. Also I put in halved carrots (unpeeled organic), onions and celery. (you can add any veggies you want. I mix in a small bowl, 3 minced garlic cloves, s@p, tyme, rosemary and sage with olive oil (about 1/2 cup, I make a big batch), and pour and stir over veggies in baking dish. Bake at 400" covered with aluminum foil for 20 min. Then uncover for 10min. You can also broil the last 10 min. for browner. That's my dish. thanks Gina H.
our favorite potatoes....
as the poster's mentioned above.. olive oil, 400 degrees with seasonings such as garlic powder, onion powder, basil, oregano, salt, pepper... whatever tickles your fancy, I've even coated them with a flour/seasoning mixture and baked them with olive oil.
So many combinations to use.. I think olive oil is the secret though.
ooops... forgot to mention...
my post above...I forgot to mention, no cover on the potatoes. Covering them makes them mushy.
microwave
Similar. Dice the potatoes similarly, place in melted butter, sprinkle with garlic powder, salt and pepper, then microwave 'til soft, stirring frequently. I like it best with red potatoes, but russetts work well too.
iron skillet cooking
I don't really have a favorite way to cook potatoes, but yesterday, in my attempts to use the iron skillet more often, I diced up three potatoes in small chunks along with some onion and then sauted them in olive oil with a little bit of salt and pepper. They came out delicious, and I served them with eggs for brunch.
~Elizabeth in Alaska
I like to mash them with all
I like to mash them with all sorts of additions: onions, chives, garlic, shallots, frozen chopped spinach, beet greens, rosemary, anything that sounds good at the moment! I also add butter/sour cream/cream cheese/milk (whatever I have at the moment!) to make them creamier. Sometimes I serve them like that and sometimes I put them in a greased baking dish, sprinkle with cheese, and bake at 350* (uncovered) until the cheese melts and they're hot all the way through.
Potatoe Salad
I like to boil em then add some
-cream cheese
-sour cream
-minced garlic
-chive
-mayonnaise
-just a little mustard to my liking.
-occasionally some crispy bacon on top (sinful)
olive oil
I agree I use olive oil, then again I'm italian and use it for everything. It also helps crisp up the potatos with out burning them. I also like fresh garlic and rosemary on mine. When I was a kid my mom would make potatos,onions,peas,and sausage in the same pan tossed in olive and spices and roasted in the oven it was one of my favs.
evoo & YOUR DISH
I use the olive oil too. Sometimes I just add salt & pepper. Other times I add more spices like garlic powder, Italian seasonings, & even minced onion. I also bake mine about 400 for 25-30 minutes stirring once.
I love your dish that the potatoes are in! It really brought back memories. We had a few dishes with that design when I was growing up. I feel a bit dumb asking this, but does this dish have a name? I mean, like a design name?
I think my mom had a smaller pan, like an 8x12 (instead of 9x13) & we also had a few bowls, maybe a small one & a larger one & they nested in one another for storage.
The blue baking dish was
The blue baking dish was from an estate sale. I particularly wanted it since it came with a glass lid (no need for foil!)... my mom has a couple glass serving bowls with that design, too. I'm not sure what it's called. It's probably rather old! I love dishes that have a practical use, plus bring back memories! :)
me too
I love dishes that bring back memories too & that blue dish sure did! :)
Potatoes and Bacon
Tammy, we make something very similar, just add onions and bacon to the mix. We cook it at 400 degrees in our roaster, stirring every 10 minutes. One of our family favorites!
Potatoes
That dish looks like FireKing, which was later bought up by Pyrex. It's lovely.
This is a really "nasty good" recipe for potatoes. ;-)
It's called Redneck Potatoes.
You cut up and boil five pounds of red-skinned potatoes. Leave the skins on. Boil like you would if you were making potato salad. Drain.
Dump in 8 oz.sour cream
chopped scallions(we love these so we use a lot of them)
4 cups shredded cheddar
1 16oz bottle of ranch salad dressing
I dump the scallions in first on the hot potatoes so they can get a little warm, then I dump in all of the rest and stir it up. Eat it like potato salad, or you can put this mess into a baking dish and melt the cheese in the oven. It's like eating a loaded baked potato. We love it.
Another thing I love to do when we grill is take a potato and put it in foil, slice it, salt, and butter, with onion soup mix. Seal the foil and let cook on the grill with the meat.
Hmmmm... I googled Fire King
Hmmmm...
I googled Fire King and couldn't find anything like this pattern. I wonder if it was just a pattern that pyrex used in the 70's?
I'd love to find out. :)
Greek Potatoes
My new favorite is something my good friend learned while in Greece...
chunked potaotes
toss in evoo
cover in lemon juice
season with oregano, salt & peper
(potatoes will be approx 1 cm of liquids)
cook at 400 uncovered for 40min-1hr
these potatoes are FULL of flavor & so moist!! My husband is a "ketchup king" and even he didn't use any on these potatoes!!
EZ Cheezy Potatoes
My family's favorite is EZ Cheezy Potatoes. The original recipe came from an entree made at the food service company I used to work for (I worked in kitchen so I didn't have privy to the actual ingredients but I made my own version). The original recipe called for frozen hashbrowns, sour cream, diced onion, cream soup and milk. I've vamped it to utilize what I buy and/or have on hand.
I used the southern style hashbrowns (one 16 oz. bag) which are the potato chunks rather than shredded like regular hashbrowns (thaw them in microwave before using). You could very easily use peeled and cubed potatoes, you'll just have to parboil them to almost done.
I use French onion chip dip (one 16 oz container) rather than the sour cream and diced onions -- I just used it as an improvision and liked the flavor just as well, and didn't have to chop onions, and if I had any left over I could use the chip dip for snacking with potato chips later...LOL.
I used 2 cans cream soup -- any flavor. The last time I made them I used Tammy's Homemade Cream of Chicken soup but had done a variation of it to make it a cream of mushroom soup... yummo!!!
I used shredded cheddar cheese (usually one 16 oz package). I personally like the sharp cheddar but it's all about your own personal taste.
You mix the potatoes, chip dip, and 1/2 of cheese together, season with salt, pepper and garlic powder if desired. Put in 9x13 baking pan and add enough milk so that it can just be seen through potato mixture -- you can always add milk if needed during baking time) Cover with foil. Bake at 350F for about 45-55 minutes. Remove foil and sprinkle with remaining cheese. Bake, uncovered for 15-20 minutes or till cheese is melted and top is browned.
I made this the last time using Tammy's Cream of Chicken Soup (altered to include mushrooms) and they went goo-goo-gaa-gaa over it. I made a double batch and absolutely none was left, eventhough there were other potato dishes with leftovers.
This dish tastes like a baked potato with sour cream!!What's nice about this recipe is you can easily double the batch, leftover freeze well andyou can make the recipe your own by adding different ingredients, although I haven't done so, like diced cooked ham or smoked sausage, sauteed, diced green/red peppers, cooked crumbled bacon, chives, etc. or whatever.
Hope you enjoy!!
Wow
There are a lot of awesome suggestions here.
I cut my potatoes in quarters and toss with olive oil. I sprinkle with Mrs. Dash well enough to coat and add water to the bottom of the dish. Cover with foil and bake at around 375, usually, until they are tender.
I've also made a foil packet. Slice my potatoes and place in the packet, sprinkle with seasoning salt, Parmesan cheese, salt and pepper. Add a few dollops of butter and bake or grill until tender.
Delicious
1. On the bottom of a baking dish, place a punch of butter and sprinkle grated parmesian cheese over it. Cut some red potatoes in half. Place the cut side down on the butter+cheese. Cook at 400* until they are soft.
2. http://crockpot365.blogspot.com/2008/11/crockpot-mashed-potatoes-with-cream.html
These are very delicious. I cut the recipe in 1/3 for three adults to eat and had some leftovers.
potatoes
I just came across this recipe on a board/forum I visit and though of you.
Crispy Potato Cubes
1/3 cup all-purpose flour
3/4 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon dried thyme
1/2 teaspoon dried marjoram
1/8 teaspoon pepper
5 medium potatoes, peeled and cut into 1-inch cubes
1/4 cup butter, melted
1 garlic clove, minced
1 bay leaf
In a large resealable plastic bag, combine the flour, salt, thyme, marjoram and
pepper. Add potatoes; seal bag and shake to coat. Pour butter into a 13-in. x
9-in. x 2-in. baking dish; stir in the garlic. Add potatoes and and bay leaf.
Cover and bake at 450° for 20 minutes. Uncover and stir; bake 15-20 minutes
longer or until potatoes are lightly browned and tender. Discard bay leaf.
Yield: 4 servings.
- Recipe source: Taste of Home magazine, October/November, 2006
Golden Parmesan Potatoes
This is a potato recipe I have been making for years.
6 Potatoes (pared and quartered)
1/4 C. Flour
1/4 C. Parmesan Cheese
3/4 t. Salt
Pepper
1/3 C. Butter
Combine flour, cheese, salt and pepper in a plastic bag. Moisten potatoes with water and shake a few at a time in bag coating potatoes well. Melt butter in 13x9 pan. Place potatoes in pan. Bake at 375 about 1 hour turning once during baking.
Just found your web site about a week ago and am pretty addicted. Have spent many hours browsing. Made roast checken and seasoned baked potatoes yesterday. Just love your vinegar and oil salad dressing; it's so light. Thanks for the recipes.
Nancy in WI
Post new comment