User login

Reader asks, reader answers: Plain white bread recipe


Amish White Bread recipe

Kimberly emailed me, asking:

I have been making homemade loaves of bread for a few months now, yet mine always turn out to be kind of dense and not at all fluffy like I think sandwich bread should be.  I looked for a recipe on your site and didn't find one.  Do you have a plain white bread recipe you prefer and wouldn't mind sharing?

Hi, Kimberly! Thanks for asking! Actually, just recently, another reader, Amy, sent me her recipe for Amish White Bread. I made it this past week, and it was very good! I didn't use all white flour in mine, but you sure can, if that's what you prefer!

My very favorite bread recipe is one with half white flour and half whole wheat flour. It's a special recipe handed down to me when I was very newly married, from a dear friend of our family. For some reason, I thought I already had it on this website, but I guess not! Keep an eye out for it in the next couple weeks, okay? :)

Now, about dense bread. That could be a result of a variety of factors besides just the recipe. Starting with warm ingredients (warm water, and flour that's at least room temperature, never cold!) and making the bread in a warm room helps mine a lot. In fact, since we keep our house fairly cool, I always turn the oven on "warm" for a few minutes, and then turn it off, and let my dough and loaves rise in there.

Also, unless we use special "conditioning" ingredients in our homemade bread dough, the homemade bread will get crumbly and dry after a day or so. It doesn't last weeks like the store-bought bread does!!

If you freeze homemade bread as SOON as it's cooled, it will be soft when you take it out to use. Another way to enjoy soft homemade bread longer than just a few days, is to wrap it in foil and warm it in the oven to accompany your meal.

I'm sure my readers have more bread-making tips, as I know some of them make fabulous homemade breads! I have to end this here (children just woke from their naps!) but I'd love to hear everyone's tips and suggestions for great homemade bread! :)

Comments

bread

I have a bread machine and I NEVER use it to bake my bread. I am known as the bread lady at church. People love to see me walk in the door with my basket. They're hoping they'll get a loaf. I have trouble keeping up with everyone who wants some. I let my bread machine do the mixing and the first rise. I then take it out and form it into whatever shape I want. If I'm in a hurry its a loaf but if I have extra time or I'm taking it to a potluck it's rolls. It's a little deceiving because people think I really go to a lot of trouble. It's really not. I think the machine does the hard part. The texture between my oven baking it and the machine baking it is so totally different that I was amazed when I discovered it. It's like night and day. The crust is so much nicer also. Putting a tablespoon of gluten in changes the texture also. Sometimes I just throw some in for kicks.

I have 2 big recipe books that are for bread machine bread. They are just fantastic. I went through them and put little stickies on all the recipes I wanted to try. Now when I have time I pull out a book and flip through and pick a new one to try. I made some foccacia the other day and it was fantastic. The kids loved it and made me put it in their lunch boxes the next day for lunch.

In conclusion....I have never made bread fully by hand. Had no desire to but wanted homemade bread. I had my bread machine for 2 years before I discovered only using the dough cycle. I've been doing it that way for the past 10 years. If I can make homemade bread anyone can. Just keep at it, the more you do it the better you get at it. My whole wheat pizza crust is fabulous but it certainly didn't start out that way. :)

Shannon

P.S. Thank you for this website. I love your recipes.

Tammy's picture

Bread dough

Shannon, thank you! I'd love to hear about your whole wheat pizza crust sometime! ;)

I have never liked the bread that my bread machine bakes. Actually, the only reason I ever got a bread machine was because a friend told me I could just use it to knead the dough. After seeing her effortless dough, I decided having one would be a real timesaver! It really is a great convenience. :)

Bread too dense

Shannon's main and correct suggestion of adding "gluten" to a recipe can be simpilfied by going to your local bulk store and buying "bread machine flour" either white or whole wheat. These flours are processed in such a way that the gluten has not been removed as in regular flours. Also some of the best recipes that can be found, are included in the owners manuals from any kitchen machine and brand you can name, just search the net and save the PDF. Hope this helps. Gourmet Guy

Tammy's picture

Bread flours

Welcome, Gourmet Guy! Thanks for commenting!

How is whole wheat bread machine flour different from normal, whole wheat flour? Is the gluten removed from normal whole wheat flour, unless one grinds their own flour?

Also, is "high-gluten flour" the same as "bread machine flour"?

Thanks for the tips -- maybe I should pull out my bread machine manual sometime. :D

Use a good mixer!

I know many people prefer to mix bread by hand but I can't do that due to some arthritis issues, so instead I use our Bosch mixer. It does a fantastic job of thoroughly kneading the dough (to better activate the gluten), and makes it so much easier to bake bread. I also use dough enhancer (usually 2 tbsp. for a batch of four loaves, but more if the yeast is older), and extra virgin olive oil, which is so much healthier than canola or vegetable oil. Our oven is electric & temperamental, so I have to let it get warm first and then I usually leave it at about 200 degrees during the rise, because otherwise it goes stone-cold again.

We usually eat homemade bread up fast, so it doesn't have a chance to get dry. I make it in batches of four loaves: I freeze two right away, one gets eaten up within a couple of hours, and then the last loaf is for the next couple of days. After that we start on the frozen ones. I'll admit, I don't always enjoy breadbaking, but there is a certain satisfaction is seeing four puffy brown loaves lined up and knowing that I made them. ;)

Tammy's picture

Homemade bread...

Sara, thanks for all that information! Where do you get your dough enhancer, and what are the ingredients? What kind(s) of flour do you use for your bread? :)

I think my oven must be hotter than yours! I have to set the timer to remember to turn the "warm" setting off after 2 or 3 minutes, so it won't kill the yeast while it's rising! :)

bread

thank you, i cant wait to try the amish white bread recipe.

WOW!!!

This bread was awesome!!! HIGHLY recommend this recipe. YUMMERS!! I thought it was a touch sweet - so I think I'll cut to 1/4 c. sugar, but I used all white bread flour. YUMMMMMMMMMMM. Love your site!! Thanks so much for the hard work!

kimberly's picture

finally!

i just got finished baking this and it turned out perfect! its fluffy just like bread should be and very tasty. (i didn't use nearly as much sugar as the recipe called for) thank you so much for posting this.

Tammy's picture

Amish White Bread recipe

Kimberly, anonymous -- thanks for sharing about trying the bread recipe! :)

Post new comment

  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
3 + 1 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Using our Amazon.com search boxes when making purchases helps support this site. Thanks for your support!